Home : Fine Italian Restaurant & Lounge - Shore Cafe - Hazlet NJMenus : Fine Italian Restaurant & Lounge - Shore Cafe - Hazlet NJBanquets : Fine Italian Restaurant & Lounge - Shore Cafe - Hazlet NJGiftCerts : Fine Italian Restaurant & Lounge - Shore Cafe - Hazlet NJAboutUs : Fine Italian Restaurant & Lounge - Shore Cafe - Hazlet NJReviews : Fine Italian Restaurant & Lounge - Shore Cafe - Hazlet NJDirections : Fine Italian Restaurant & Lounge - Shore Cafe - Hazlet NJContactUs : Fine Italian Restaurant & Lounge - Shore Cafe - Hazlet NJ
Fine Italian Restaurant & Lounge - Shore Cafe - Hazlet NJ
Fine Italian Restaurant & Lounge - Shore Cafe - Hazlet NJ

Fine Italian Restaurant & Lounge - Shore Cafe - Hazlet NJ (The Bayshore Courier)
CourierOPINION
Hello, Hazlet! Celebrating a real "Hometown, USA"
February 2, 2004
I am Eileen Coughlin and my husband, Paul, is the mayor of Hazlet.

The Courier recently asked me if I would write a monthly column. As you can see, my answer was "yes."

The basic premise of the column will be to discuss social events, activities, dining experiences and intriguing life stories. I will also discuss several Hazlet organizations and highlight community success stories. I will avoid politics completely.

Now that the introduction is done, I'd like to encourage people to contact me with any input you may have that I can incorporate into the column.

Each month, I will finish with a Hazlet dining experience that I've recently had.

The first review is of The Shore Cafe, Highway 36, Hazlet.

The night out at the Shore Cafe is a palate pleaser. The menu varies but clearly has an Italian theme.

The specials, as presented by the fine waiting staff, will leave you with a "can't wait to get started" attitude.

We started off with shrimp scampi as an appetizer. That produced some beautiful jumbo shrimp. The civilized, nonchalant battle for the shrimp, once you start eating, is only surpassed by the rapid dipping of the fine Italian bread into the scampi sauce.
The sauce in one word is "fantastic." The salad is a nice lead up to the entree with its sweet house taste. For our main course, we went with the veal saltimbocca off the main menu as well as the stuffed filet mignon for the specials.

The veal dish was fantastic with the prosciutto, mozzarella and nice lean tenderloin. The veal was accompanied with pasta.

Now, on to my filet, and mouth watering would be an underestimation of the impact this will have on your taste buds.

The filet is stuffed with sun-dried tomatoes, shrimp and cheese. The dish also comes with a nice batch of roasted potatoes and in this case the host disappears before the company but not by long.

The desert menu and after dinner drink offerings are all of a top quality. The bottom line is: A fabulous dining experience, with a special ambiance, right in the heart of the Bayshore.


Fine Italian Restaurant & Lounge - Shore Cafe - Hazlet NJ (Courier Dining)  Shore Cafe Italian Bistro & Lounge: Superb Cuisine Plus Pleasant Ambiance

Courier Dining
Shore Cafe Italian Bistro & Lounge: Superb Cuisine Plus Pleasant Ambiance
By Lynn Azzolina
HAZLET - The Shore Cafe brings you the flavor of Italy with fine, quality cuisine second to none. The family operated restaurant imparts that at-home feeling as the hospitality is warm and the atmosphere is friendly. They are dedicated to bringing their customers the finest food possible, and the menu is studded with alluring Italian specialties which will tempt your palate.

I found it very difficult to select my entree, as everything was appealing , all made to order. They aim to please each and every patron, and that is why people return again and again.

Taking charge of the kitchen is John Conti, Jr.., whose parents, John and Ann Conti, opened the Shore Cafe early in July. They have already established a fine reputation amongst lovers of good Italian food, who have become their regulars.

Ann's parents came here from Italy, and opened a restaurant in Staten Island, named Three J's, for three brothers, Jack, Joe and John. Because this was so successful, they opened up a larger restaurant, called J's Villa. Ann learned from her mother and father and, in turn, she taught her sons John Jr., who is executive chef, and Michael, who is manager.

The dwelling for Shore Cafe was originally known as Paulin's Tavern. The entire building was gutted out and renovated, creating a magnificent, upscale ambiance. A package, modern liquor store is located on the side of the building.
When you enter, you will step into a lounge area with a circular bar boasting an imported granite top. The attractive floors are imported Italian marble, coordinated with a patterned carpet in the dining area. There are two dining sections, one for non-smoking. Upon entering, your eyes will spot a life-size mural, which is breathtaking, a colorful scene depicting the shore of Ann's family town, named Sferracavallo. This is a sight to behold!

The entire restaurant is pleasant and comfortable, with a touch of elegance. Tables are clothed and surrounded by attractive wooden, upholstered chairs. The room is light and airy, with the entire front and side covered with wooden paned, floor-to-ceiling windows.

A point of interest, which is also very unique, is the glass partition, which separates the lounge from the dining area, made of sea glass. The entire decor was designed by Ann herself.

The Contis plan to build another dining area, which will accommodate 75 people, making the entire capacity 150.

Now for the food: I cannot say enough about the quality and preparation of everything that was served. Every dish that was brought to the table was impeccable, beautifully presented, and designed to satisfy even the most discriminating diner. Everything on the menu has that homemade flavor, and the sauces are exceptional.
To begin, the Cold Seafood Platter, an appetizer, was a meal in itself. The large, colorful, and attractive platter was filled with shrimp, calamari, scungilli, and mussels, marinated in extra virgin olive oil and lemon. All of the fresh-tasting seafood was abundant with flavor. In the center of the platter was an array of fresh greens, celery, Jersey tomatoes, and slivered carrots, enhanced by the flavorful dressing. Outstanding!

The Red Snapper Marechiare, that was served next, was impeccable. A large portion of seafood, enriched with black olives, capers and tomatoes in an enticing and perfectly made red sauce. This was created by a very caring chef, who put a lot of love into the preparation.

We were then served Veal Saltimbocca, another sensational creation. The large portion of fork-tender veal was smothered with fresh mozzarella cheese, layered with fresh spinach and prosciutto, and accented with fresh mushrooms, in a delicate brown sauce. This was a treat for the palate, the veal superbly seasoned, and exhilarating entree made to perfection.

Our waitress, Ashley Green of Howell, was very caring, and made our dining experience very pleasant. As a grand finale, we sampled John Jr.'s homemade tira mi su. This is a must-try, a perfect ending to a gourmet meal. It was light, not cloyingly sweet, creamy, and absolutely delicious, worth every forbidden calorie. John also makes his own cannoli and cheese cake.
Dinner entrees range from $14.95 for Chicken Marsala, Parmigiana or Picata, to $24.95, for Zuppa de Pesce o Linguine. The majority of their entrees are under $19.95.

The Shore Cafe is also known for their gourmet pizzas and calzones. They also serve a variety of specialty pastas, chicken dishes, steaks, chops and seafood.

A pizza favorite is Autumno Pizza, which has sliced tomato, artichoke hearts, mushrooms, and cheese.

A unique pasta is Farfalle Blanco Rosso - homemade sausage and fresh tomatoes in cream and basil sauce.

The Shore Cafe, 1104 Highway 36, Hazlet, is open seven days for lunch and dinner; Monday-Saturday, 9a - 10p; Sunday, 2p - 9p.

They accept all major credit cards, there is parking in their lot, and the restaurant is handicapped accessible. They will also cater private parties.

Reservations are suggested, call 732-888-0288


Fine Italian Restaurant & Lounge - Shore Cafe - Hazlet NJ (The Bayshore Courier) Shore Cafe Italian Bistro: Family Operated Offering Authentic, Excuisite Cuisine

 
Bayshore Courier Dining Guide
Shore Cafe Italian Bistro: Family Operated Offering Authentic, Exquisite Cuisine
October 16, 2003
HAZLET - Dining here is a memorable experience and you will want to return soon and sample everything on the diversified menu. The restaurant has only been open for a year and a half, and have acquired a fine reputation with patrons returning again and again. The reason for this is that they treat their customers like family, making them comfortable and catering to their special requests. The cuisine is spectacular with everything prepared to order.

The family-operated eatery owned by the Conti family, is headed by John and Ann, and their sons John Jr. and Michael. They are dedicated to excellence and quality is their motto. Prices are affordable and the menu is studded with irresistible Italian specialties, which are second to none. All of their recipes are homemade originating from Italy with an American touch.

Taking charge of the kitchen is John Conti, Jr. and Craig Harden. Together they have over twenty-five years experience in the culinary field, and they both excel in everything that they prepare. John's brother Michael is the general manager and he has been very successful in the operation of the restaurant, making sure that each and every customer is completely satisfied. It is because of their family dedication and the fact that they all work together that has flourished in such a short time.
Upon entering you will spot a life size mural, which is breathtaking, a colorful scene depicting the shore of Ann Conti's family town, named Sferracavallo. This will give you the feeling of actually being there, it is so striking.

The entire restaurant is pleasant and comfortable, with a touch of elegance. The entire decor was designed by Ann herself. The Contis plan to enlarge the facility very soon to accommodate additional private functions, adding 70 more seats. Italian background music will also add to your dining pleasure. We thoroughly enjoyed our entire dinner, which was delightful from the appetizers to the luscious desserts. They strive to please, and and each dish that came out of the kitchen was a work of art, looking like it came out of a gourmet magazine. Everything had that homemade flavor and their sauces were exceptional. The restaurant is ideal for family dining and you can order anything from a specialty pasta dish, seafood, steaks, chops and chicken to a gourmet pizza.

The wait staff at The Shore Cafe is impeccable, headed by Captain Carlos. He was assisted by Gianni Archoekas. They were both very professional and accommodating, making our dining experience a very pleasant one.
As soon as you are seated you will be served a wonderful Eggplant Carbonata (made here) to spread on your freshly baked Italian bread from Brooklyn. I absolutely loved it!

The Crab Cakes that came next were robust, with all fresh, lump crabmeat, and only enough filler to hold it together. This was enhanced with a very flavorful Dijon mustard sauce, which added a pleasant touch of spice. A real taste treat!

I absolutely loved the Filet of Sole Oreganata stuffed with crabmeat, shrimp and scallops, broiled with a touch of lemon. The sole was fresh tasting, succulent, and filled with the delicious seafood, which had an abundance of flavor. This was an exquisite offering that would please anyone who is a seafood lover.

The Stuffed Filet Mignon that was served next was just as exhilarating - a generous portioned steak, prepared to our specifications enhanced with a goat cheese, mascarpone cheese, shiitake mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes, shrimp and roasted garlic filling. This is a unique preparation, perfectly made by a professional creative chef. The filet was accompanied with potatoes au gratin and fresh broccoli. A luxurious offering!
Another dish of distinction which shouldn't be missed is Snapper Pompeii. This is fresh red snapper teamed with artichoke hearts, fresh asparagus, sun dried tomatoes, and mushrooms, complimented with a lemon herb sauce and placed over a bed of rice. The snapper was flaky, filled with an abundance of flavor and a dish that I would not hesitate to order on my next visit.

Dinner entrees range from $14.94 for Chicken Parmigiana to $24.99 for Zuppa di Pesce. The majority of their entrees are under $19.95.

The Shore Cafe is located at 1104 Highway 356, Hazlet, open seven days for lunch and dinner.

They accept all major credit cards, have plenty of parking in their log and the restaurant is handicap accessible. They will also cater private parties.

Reservations are suggested. Call 732-888-0288